There's the first one. There's the right one. And there's the one you never forget.
In a 1966 New Jersey high school, Jill and new student Sheik from the other side of the tracks make their way in a first love romance.
Stewart
Steve
Jill Rosen
Stage Manager
Vinnie
Waitress
Mr. McManus, Teacher
Mrs. Rosen
Albert 'Sheik' Capadilupo
Dr. Rosen
Mrs. Capadilupo
Phillip
Leslie, College Girl
Biff
Lew
Jody, High School Girl
Mr. Ripeppi, Teacher
Debra, High School Girl
Miss Vernon, Teacher
Joann